I wouldn't think giving points would work, but treating it like a flagrant where you get a FT (or two) by any player on the court, and the ball would keep it to a minimum.EDC wrote:I dunno about that. You could easily scale the penalty to make it really costly to the other team. You could even remove free throws from the penalty. Non shooting foul over say 5 would give the other team 1 point and the ball. Non shooting foul over 6 is 2 points for the other team and the ball.
You could definitely curb the fouling by increasing the penalty.
The whole point of a system like this is to reduce the impact of bad calls on the out come of the game. The refs aren't perfect. I also feel that it would free them up to not have to worry about who has fouled who and just call the game as they see it.
Around the League: Week 23 3/27 - 4/2
Re: Around the League: Week 23 3/27 - 4/2
Re: Around the League: Week 23 3/27 - 4/2
That is an interesting idea.Indy wrote:I wouldn't think giving points would work, but treating it like a flagrant where you get a FT (or two) by any player on the court, and the ball would keep it to a minimum.EDC wrote:I dunno about that. You could easily scale the penalty to make it really costly to the other team. You could even remove free throws from the penalty. Non shooting foul over say 5 would give the other team 1 point and the ball. Non shooting foul over 6 is 2 points for the other team and the ball.
You could definitely curb the fouling by increasing the penalty.
The whole point of a system like this is to reduce the impact of bad calls on the out come of the game. The refs aren't perfect. I also feel that it would free them up to not have to worry about who has fouled who and just call the game as they see it.
Re: Around the League: Week 23 3/27 - 4/2
It's not even summer yet, and we've got one thread with the suggestion that all fouls should always be the worst possible play, and another thread suggesting that players should never foul out.
Be honest with me: how sober are you guys right now?
Be honest with me: how sober are you guys right now?
The league needs heroes, villains... and clowns. -- Aztec Sunsfan
Re: Around the League: Week 23 3/27 - 4/2
The ideas are perfectly compatibleO_Gardino wrote:It's not even summer yet, and we've got one thread with the suggestion that all fouls should always be the worst possible play, and another thread suggesting that players should never foul out.
Be honest with me: how sober are you guys right now?

Re: Around the League: Week 23 3/27 - 4/2
Hermen wrote:The ideas are perfectly compatibleO_Gardino wrote:It's not even summer yet, and we've got one thread with the suggestion that all fouls should always be the worst possible play, and another thread suggesting that players should never foul out.
Be honest with me: how sober are you guys right now?and honestly, I don't take the discussions here as a matter of life and death, or I'd consult with a lawyer before posting.

The league needs heroes, villains... and clowns. -- Aztec Sunsfan
Re: Around the League: Week 23 3/27 - 4/2
A) WordHermen wrote:The ideas are perfectly compatibleO_Gardino wrote:It's not even summer yet, and we've got one thread with the suggestion that all fouls should always be the worst possible play, and another thread suggesting that players should never foul out.
Be honest with me: how sober are you guys right now?and honestly, I don't take the discussions here as a matter of life and death, or I'd consult with a lawyer before posting.
B) Double-word